TikTok US Marketplace The Game Has Changed Self Operated Channels Are Replacing Influencers as the New Trend

Sep 23, 2025

Leave a message

Collaborating with influencers used to be the "golden rule" for merchants to quickly scale sales on TikTok. But this year, more and more sellers are complaining: Why is it getting harder to find reliable influencers who can actually drive sales?

Today, let's have an honest conversation about what's happening with TikTok influencer partnerships-why they've become so "challenging," and what strategies will truly deliver results now.

01

TikTok's Earning Models Operate on a "Cycle"

TikTok isn't a platform where you can stick to one method and profit indefinitely. It has its own "model cycle"-essentially, waves of opportunity ebb and flow, and once a wave passes, you need to adapt.

Why does this happen? Because TikTok's operational strategies are constantly evolving, with different approaches gaining dominance in each phase. At the core, though, the key to profitability boils down to four words: ​channel efficiency.

What does this mean? When a new model first emerges and hasn't been fully exploited, early adopters reap sky-high returns-influencer marketing was exactly this.

02

TikTok US Influencer Marketing: From Boom to Bust

​Early Days: Unprecedented Efficiency​

Remember when TikTok first blew up in the US? Influencer marketing was absurdly effective back then. I know a friend who ran one of the earliest US-based MCN/TAP agencies-they were making $8 million a month at their peak. I'll admit, I was green with envy.

Why was it so explosive? Back then, many US influencers had hundreds of thousands or even millions of followers but had never done paid promotions. If you partnered with them-even if your video was low-budget-their fans would buy based on novelty and trust. At its height, influencer-driven sales accounted for over 70% of TikTok's total sales. Calling it the "profit engine" was no exaggeration.

​Later Stages: A Sharp Decline in Efficiency​

Then, everyone saw the profits and rushed in, flooding the market with influencer collaborations. Suddenly, influencers were bombarding their followers with ads daily. Fans grew tired: "Why are you pushing products every day? I don't want to see this anymore!" Conversion rates plummeted.

Worse, the supply of high-quality influencers couldn't keep up with merchant demand, creating a severe imbalance. Nowadays, new sellers in the US TikTok space often face this reality: Either influencers refuse to cooperate-they'll take your free product but drag their feet on posting; or they're unreliable, producing videos that barely move the needle. The truth? Most influencers you can access now are "second- or third-tier." The top-tier ones were already snatched up by major sellers.

But there's no avoiding it: In mature markets like the US, where TikTok's ecosystem has reached its third phase, influencer marketing is destined to grow overcrowded. Declining channel efficiency is inevitable.

03

It's Time to Rethink Influencer Partnerships

If you still rely solely on influencers, many merchants will find themselves stuck in a passive, inefficient rut. But by building self-operated channels, you can shift from reactive to proactive, achieving more stable and scalable growth.

First, since the second half of this year, self-operated short videos have been accounting for an increasing share of TikTok's top charts. This isn't a coincidence-it's a signal that self-operated channels are rapidly gaining efficiency, with their "golden window" already visible.

Second, for small and medium-sized sellers, self-operated channels are the most efficient and cost-effective. Influencer partnerships should only serve as a "multiplier" to amplify results. If you can first build foundational sales for your product via self-operated content, collaborating with influencers later will drastically improve your success rate.

Third, once you master self-operated channels, you can reverse-engineer the "viral logic" of your product to guide influencers. The reality is: Most second- or third-tier influencers don't understand content creation or short-video sales. At best, they might grasp your product's basic features-but they won't think through its unique selling points, target audience, pain points, or how to hook viewers in the first three seconds. These critical elements require yourteam's content expertise to empower influencers, which is the only way to boost their conversion rates effectively.

In closing: Markets evolve, and so do efficient channels. The decline in influencer efficiency is just a symptom. Beneath it lies a structural shift in channel efficiency as the US TikTok market matures.

The real breakthrough lies in recognizing this reality: ​Self-operated channels are replacing influencers as the new efficiency frontier. Only by aligning with the platform's rhythm and understanding the essence of this shift can you avoid clinging to outdated methods and getting left behind.

Send Inquiry